← Back to Blog

When Parents Undermine Your Expertise

When “Just One More” Feels Like So Much More

It starts small. A parent says “just one more book” at bedtime, even though you know it will push sleep later. At the store, they give in to a toy to stop the tears, even though tomorrow the same request will come again. At home, they let the child skip dressing themselves because it takes too long and they’re already late. On the walk to school, they carry the backpack because it’s easier than dealing with the protest. At mealtimes, they let the child snack on whatever they want because they don’t have the energy for another negotiation. When the child refuses to brush their teeth or tidy up their toys, the parent moves on, knowing the nanny will take care of it. She always does.

What feels like a tiny shortcut in the moment creates bigger ripples later, late bedtimes turn into overtired mornings, skipped steps delay independence, and routines you’ve carefully built start to crumble. The child quickly learns that boundaries shift depending on who’s in charge, and they begin testing limits even more.

For the nanny, it feels like the work that was meant to focus on helping the child build consistency, manage their emotions, and grow resilience has transformed into managing chaos, endless negotiations, and daily tantrums.

Unfortunately, parents don’t always see how much weight those small moments carry. What feels like a simple choice to keep the day moving, a way to hold on to a bit of calm, can quietly shape the rhythm of the days that follow. Without meaning to, each little compromise makes the next one harder, and the lines that once felt clear begin to blur.

Why Parents Undermine (It’s Not Always Distrust)

It’s easy to assume that parents who undermine your expertise don’t value your knowledge, but most of the time, the reasons are more complicated and deeply human. Some parents feel an overwhelming guilt for working long hours, and when they finally get time with their kids, they want to be the fun, “yes” parent, not the one who enforces bedtime, routines, or tears.

Others are simply too drained by their own demanding lives to face another battle of wills with a toddler. After a stressful day, avoiding a tantrum feels like self-preservation. They don’t always see how their small decisions in those moments can create bigger problems later, or how it shifts the emotional and logistical weight onto someone else.

Sometimes life simply feels chaotic and they need quick fixes, saying yes to avoid the crying in the store, letting the child stay up late instead of dealing with the bedtime protest, carrying the backpack to avoid the morning meltdown. They may not notice that each “yes” takes away an opportunity for the child to learn independence or emotional resilience.

What they also might not realize is that these moments of avoidance create a power imbalance, not just between parent and nanny, but also in how the child perceives boundaries. In the end, it’s the caregiver who is left holding those fragile lines, trying to keep things stable in an environment where the rules are constantly changing.

Small Missteps, Big Turnover

While there isn’t a formal large-scale study on why nannies leave their positions, countless personal stories shared online highlight the same recurring themes, poor communication, blurred boundaries, and feeling undervalued. Here are a few voices from the nanny community:

"I've tried multiple times to talk... to get on the same page, but it just seems that they do not want to deal with... so they give them whatever they want. (...) Ask me to enforce rules, but they never follow through so nothing sticks. I feel as though I've lost all "power/authority"."
— Reddit user, r/Nanny, February 5, 2019

"First they told me they needed NK in the new room and toddler bed by March. The day we decided to transition to the toddler bed for naptime I got there and they had reverted it back to a crib. They had not tried once to have him sleep in there and neither did I. They told me it’s “what he wanted”."
— Reddit user, r/Nanny, February 9, 2023

It’s important to understand: when nannies leave unexpectedly, they aren’t simply walking away from a job, they’re stepping out of a household dynamic where their role and limits were never clearly respected. And the impact reaches far beyond the adults. When trust and communication are weak, it creates instability in the household, high turnover, and a constant cycle of re-adjustment.

For children, this inconsistency often shows up later in ways that go beyond tantrums. A lack of predictable routines and clear boundaries can make it harder for them to feel confident in new environments, these are the kids who may withdraw or become overly shy in school.

Without consistency at home, they struggle with focus and follow-through, which reflects in their schoolwork. Socially, it can affect their ability to form deeper friendships; empathy and flexibility are harder to develop when they’re used to rules and expectations revolving around their own immediate needs. Over time, what started as blurred boundaries at home can quietly shape how they handle challenges, relationships, and independence in the world beyond it.

It’s Really a Communication Problem

At its core, the breakdown often comes from both sides. Parents sometimes avoid accountability, agreeing to routines but not following through, or treating the nanny as someone who should simply adapt without question. They may lack the teamwork needed to approach challenges as a united front. On the other hand, nannies often hold back from voicing solutions or addressing patterns directly, afraid of overstepping or damaging the relationship. Without honest communication, small problems grow quietly into bigger ones, and everyone, especially the child, feels the weight of that misalignment.

In the end, it’s entirely a parent’s choice how they want to raise their children. But when they invite someone else into that space, consistency and mutual respect become essential. Because if the nanny is expected to share in the work, yet not in the decisions, the burden of the consequences will always fall back on the family.

Tantrums, mealtime refusal, bedtime chaos, these small moments quietly shape how kids learn boundaries and independence. Want to see how to make them calmer? Try our Daily Parenting Moments that show short, real-life scenarios with simple tips to handle them with confidence.