← Back to Blog

Mom Guilt

The Guilt Gap

She didn’t hire a nanny to replace herself. She hired one to make more possible, for her child, and for herself. More moments of discovery, more one-on-one attention, more everyday patience. Between meetings, mealtimes, and meltdowns, she wanted her child to feel seen, supported, and cared for. But then, one night, while helping with pajamas, her toddler says, “That’s not how the nanny does it.” A twist in her chest catches her off guard. Jealousy? Guilt? Or maybe fear that someone else is doing it better?

This is the quiet truth many moms face, even when they’re home. Whether you’re answering emails in the next room, stepping out for errands, or working full-time while your child builds trust with a caregiver, the guilt doesn’t disappear. It just changes shape.

A 2023 study published in Frontiers in Psychology found that maternal guilt isn’t just about time, it’s about identity. Mothers often internalize the belief that being present means being irreplaceable. And when a nanny enters the picture, even temporarily, that belief can feel threatened.

This isn't a personal flaw, it's a cultural script. A 2022 McKinsey study found that 80% of mothers feel guilt related to their parenting choices, regardless of employment status. Stay-at-home moms reported feeling judged for “not contributing,” while working moms felt judged for “not being present.”

Ironically, moms with more support, like a reliable nanny, often wrestle with the idea that parenting should be a solo act. You may find yourself overcompensating, squeezing connection into tight margins, or downplaying the value your childcare provider adds.

What the Research Says

• Universal Guilt: A 2021 APA report found that 63% of mothers experienced increased guilt during the pandemic, even when home full-time.
• Invisible Labor: The same McKinsey report noted that women spend 20+ hours more per week than men on unpaid caregiving, often without recognition, leading to burnout and internalized guilt.
• Quality vs. Quantity: According to research published in the Journal of Marriage and Family, the amount of time a parent spends with a child has less impact on emotional outcomes than the quality of that time.

Different Paths, Same Pressure

Mom guilt is rarely about the logistics of childcare, it’s emotional, cultural, and deeply personal. Whether you parent full-time or split the load with a caregiver, you’ve probably heard your own inner critic whisper:

• Working mom: “I miss my baby all day.”
• Stay-at-home mom: “I miss feeling like me.”
• Part-time mom with a nanny: “I feel selfish for needing help.”
• Stay-at-home with a nanny: “I’m home all day, why do I still feel like I’m failing?”

Where the Guilt Comes From

• Social media: Perfectly curated reels of smiling kids and spotless homes don’t show the behind-the-scenes reality.
• Gender roles: Research shows moms still shoulder most emotional labor, even with hired help.
• “Good Mom” myths: We’re told to be fully present, professionally ambitious, emotionally regulated, and always grateful.

"(...) So grateful that my daughter has someone else in her life other than her parents that cares for her and takes her out and does fun things with her. I’m just so jealous that person isn’t me on weekdays from 9-5."
— Reddit user, r/Mommit, March 25, 2025

"I am very glad I can relax for 8 hours during the day to catch up some sleep and focus more on self care but at the same time I feel so guilty not taking care of my (baby) myself while I’m still on leave."
— Reddit user, r/Nanny, February 28, 2023

Support Isn’t a Shortcut, It’s a Strategy

When families bring in a nanny, it’s not an escape from parenting. It’s an expansion of what care can look like. And yet, many parents still wrestle with the feeling that they’re "outsourcing" love, when in fact they’re reinforcing it by reducing burnout and increasing presence.

Whether you’re working 60 hours a week or staying home full-time, guilt often stems not from your actions, but from the unrealistic expectations placed on modern parents. Social media doesn’t help. Neither do highlight reels of perfectly balanced families.

Reframing the Voice

So how do you quiet the guilt? Not by doing more. But by recognizing that guilt often shows up not as a sign of failure, but as evidence that you care deeply.

You’re not less of a parent when you accept help. You’re more resourced. Your child benefits not just from your presence, but from your well-being, and your ability to show up with joy instead of depletion.

Reframing the Guilt

British psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott coined the term “good enough mother” in his 1953 work "Transitional Objects and Transitional Phenomena", emphasizing that children don’t need perfection rather safe, responsive, and imperfect care. He argued that maternal "failures" (e.g., not meeting every need immediately) are essential for a child’s emotional development and ability to tolerate frustration. Guilt, in this context, can signal how deeply a parent cares, not how badly they’re failing.

"You feel guilty because you're trying to be everything. But what your child really needs... is you, showing up, imperfectly."
— Paraphrasing Donald Winnicott’s *"good enough mother"* theory, as discussed in Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine

Mom guilt doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong. It means you care. Whether you work full-time, stay home, or fall somewhere in between, remember: parenting is never one-size-fits-all, but guilt often is. Let’s start rewriting that story. Check out our Coping Toolkit for useful tips that help you tackle your guilt.